I don't read many books. Aside from the yearly book that I receive as an x-mas present from my Aunt & Uncle and the occasional work related book, I really can't recall the last book I read. That is not to say however, that I don't read much. In fact, I think I almost spend a little to much time reading.
Of the wide assortment of things that I read up on, which ranges from whatever
The Wall Street Journal is reporting to the latest in sports, I have recently found myself focusing a lot more on fitness related topics. For the most part, the majority of these articles are opinion based (resulting from personal experiences), while a smaller portion are more focused on the more technical aspects of how things work.
From what I have read, I have come to this conclusion:
Everything works.Everything?Yes, everything.Simply put, in regards to fitness programs, everything out there works to some degree. The catch is that it might not work for you. Sticking with tradition, let me try to use an analogy to explain this.
Choose Your Own Adventure/Light Bulb A light bulb in your house goes out. What do you do? Well, you take your ass down to the hardware store to buy yourself a new one.
So you do that. Now you are at the hardware store, standing in the lighting section, wondering which one of the 100 different types of light bulbs you need. Depending on who you are, or what you know, this could lead to a few different scenarios.
Scenario 1: You know nothing about light bulbs, so you ask someone for help. When they ask you what size light bulb you need you just stare at them with a blank look on your face.
"Uhh... one that gives off light?" Using those parameters, the "helpful" sales associate hands you a light bulb and tells you to go try it.
Once home, you take your new light bulb out of the package and then...
1) Scratch your head because you have no idea how to install it.
2) Electrocute yourself because you forget to turn the light switch to off before installing it.
3) You find that the light bulb is not the right size.
4) Install it successfully.
If you picked option 1 or 2, you are pretty much hopeless. Sorry. Game over.
If you went with option 3, you go back to the store with your light bulb and return it, saying that
"the light bulb doesn't work." Secretly, the person at the
Returns counter is thinking to themself
"Of course the light bulb works. You just chose the wrong one, idiot" but of course they don't say that out loud. Instead, they suggest another light bulb that might work for you. At this point, you go home with your light bulb and repeat the steps above.
If you chose option 4, you smile to yourself happily. That is, until you realize later that
a) The light bulb is not energy is efficient.
b) The light bulb gives off a crappy yellowish light, versus the bright white light you wanted.
c) You don't realize anything because you are just happy that you have light again.
Scenario 2:Since you are an intelligent individual (not that I'm saying people the fall into scenario 1 aren't), you brought the burnt out bulb with you. You quickly identify the same bulb and purchase it.
Once home, you take your new light bulb out of the package and then...
1) Install the light bulb, only to remember,
"hey wait, I don't even like the light this bulb gives off, why the hell did I buy this same bulb again?"2) Are completely satisfied with your new light bulb. Who cares if it isn't energy efficient? Not you.
/end analogyOkay, so we (both you and I) probably could have done without that analogy. What I am trying to get at here is that if someone took the time to write about some fitness program they did, it is probably because of one of following:
a) They got results, liked their results, and think you should do the same.
b) Got results, but they weren't the results they wanted. Regardless, they learned from it and are trying to share that knowledge with you.
c) Were lazy and didn't work hard, and have decided that the program they used sucks and they want to share that with everyone to shift the blame.
Whatever the reason, the program itself most likely "works." That is to say, if you are starting at point A, this program will get you to point B. Problems arise when you aren't starting from point A and they get even worse when point B isn't your goal.
So what then? How do you find something that will work for you?First off, it helps to know where you are. Simply knowing that will eliminate half of the fitness programs out there. If someone is extremely obese and has a very limited range of motion it won't exactly benefit them to jump into an Olympic Lifting program. On the flip side, it wouldn't be very beneficial for an Olympic lifter to walk on a treadmill for 30 minutes a day. Will either of these programs be of some benefit? Probably. Are they remotely the best choices for these individuals given their respective starting points? Absolutely not.
The next question is, where do you want to be? What is your goal? For some people this is easy: they want to be in better shape. Sadly, this tell us nothing. Who doesn't want to be in better shape? Given that goal, pretty much ANYTHING will work... for a time. More often then not, there will be some part of a program that just doesn't work for you and you will drop it.
For instance, the program you go on might require you to workout 5 days a week. Given the goal of being in better shape, this program should have been a perfect fit. But it isn't. Why? Because maybe you don't have the time to work out 5 days a week. Maybe you can only work out three. In this case, your goal really should have been "to get into better shape using a program that only requires me to work out 3 times a week."
Using another analogy here (a short one this time)...
It's like a smoker saying their goal is to stop smoking, except not wanting to give up nicotine. That sort of limits things, doesn't it?
With goals come sacrifices. If you don't know what you are willing to give up to reach a goal then it is hard to find a program that will help you reach your goal without some trial and error.
For others, their goal may be more specific. Their goals may be to be faster, stronger, or better looking. But again, while there may be 5 different programs for each out there, not all of them will fit into the sacrifices that you are willing to make for them to be successful. However, if you know what sacrifices you are willing to make this might narrow the programs down to 1-2. You may even come to find there aren't any programs out there for you. In this case, you may need to re-evaluate your goals or even the sacrifices you are willing to make.
Another disconnect that occurs is when people do something fitness related and they don't know why. They might know exactly where they are, and exactly where they want to be, except they end up choosing a program that just doesn't fit them. Why do they do it? Because they don't know any better, or the person that told them to do something doesn't know any better.
Everything works, and if you are lucky, it might even work for you to some degree. Whether it is optimal for you, given your goals and the sacrifices you are willing to make, is the question, and honestly, you might not care if it is optimal, as the program might fit you well and you are able to sustain it. Just being able to sustain a fitness program is a goal to many people.
If however, you can determine where you are, where you want to be, what you are willing to sacrifice, and put in the time to research why you are doing what you are doing, chances are that you will find something that not only works, but works for YOU.
All this aside, I like CrossFit.
Is it for everyone? No.
Is it scalable so that anyone can do it? Yes.
Does it allow for flexibility for people at different starting points or with different goals that may need to have an emphasis on specific componenets of fitness? Yes.
Does it work for me? Yes.
Can it work for you? Yes.
Will it be optimal for you? That depends...
-dunkie
Side note: This idea that all fitness programs essentially "work, just not ncessarily for you" has a lot of parrellels to the financial/investment industry. When it comes to investing, a lot of people have the goal to just "make as much money as possible." This is great, until their investment guy takes that idea and runs with it, and then they come to find out that their guy basically went to Vegas and bet all of their money red. For most, they are not willing to take that amount of risk, even if the potential return are great. The problem is, if they don't say that, they might find themselves in a "program" that doesn't fit them.
If you are able to identify where you are, where you want to be, and what sacrifices you are willing to make to get here then you will be taking a step in the right direction. After that, the next step should be to educate yourself so that they can find a "program"or "investment strategy" that works for you.p.s. If you actually made it through this entire post without becoming lost and/or confused, I applaud you. I got lost just trying to proof read it...and I wrote the damn thing.